Rifabutin and Macrolide Antibiotic Treatment in Crohn’s
Patients Identified Serologically Positive for Mycobacterium avium ss.
paratuberculosis
I. Shafran, C. Piromalli, S. A. Naser
Gastroenterology 118(4): A4182 (2000)
Abstract
The use of antibiotics in Crohn’s disease has recently been studied
and our group has shown previously the efficacy and safety of RMAT in an
open clinical trial. Forty-two Crohn’s patients, who were serologically
positive with the p35 and p36 serologic markers specific for Mycobacterium
avium ss. paratuberculosis (MAP), were chosen for treatment with Rifabutin
and Macrolide Antibiotic Therapy (RMAT). The RMAT medications included
250 mgm 1 po bid clarithromycin and 150 mgm 1 po bid rifabutin and 200
mgm po bid of a probiotic containing equal amounts of Lactobacillus acidophilus
and Lactobacillus rhamnosus. These patients were followed serologically
and clinically each month. The serial blood samples were stored to measure,
at a later date, the quantitative antibody response to MAP. 7 patients
withdrew from the study since they were unable to tolerate medications.
The 35 remaining patients were assessed to determine their overall response
to treatment. The period of treatment ranged from 6 months to 22 months
with the average treatment period being 8.5 months. 77.1% (27/35) of the
patients reached a sustained state of clinical remission while being off
all other Crohn’s medications, such as immunosuppresants and corticosteroids.
The majority of these patients had acute presentations of Crohn’s disease
when placed on RMAT. 5 patients also had documented endoscopic healing
correlating with treatment response. 8.6% (3/35) of patients noticed significant
improvements but were still using Crohn’s medications with RMAT. 14.3%
(5/35) were non-responders noticing no marked improvement while on RMAT.
16.7% (7/42) of patients were unable to tolerate the RMAT medications and
withdrew from the study within two months of treatment noticing no improvements.
These findings add further evidence to support the role of RMAT in the
treatment of Crohn’s disease in patients serologically positive for MAP.
A large multicenter clinical trial is needed to further explore these findings.
RMAT CLINICAL TRIAL RESULTS
| RMAT |
Patients
|
Percent (%)
|
| Responders |
27
|
27/35 (77.1%)
|
| Partial Responders |
3
|
3/35 (8.6%)
|
| Non-Responders |
5
|
5/35 (14.3%)
|
| Withdrawal |
7
|
7/42 (16.7%)
|
Background
Refractory Crohn’s Disease and the Role of Antibiotics
Therapeutic options in refractory Crohn’s disease are limited. Although
wide spread use of immunosuppressants has reduced the number of intractable
cases, patients not responding to this therapy often become dependent on
Corticosteroids and as a result, eventually undergo debilitating surgical
resections.
Antibiotics have been found to resolve secondary complications due to
abscess and fistulae formation associated with abnormal bacterial colonization.
Antibiotics have also been used as curative therapies directed against
proposed etiological agents.
Although studies have shown a general therapeutic role of antibiotics,
these studies have had mixed results most likely due to study design, use
of inappropriate antibiotics, brevity of treatment durations, and lack
of evidence for the presence of an etiologic agent.1
To effectively treat CD patients with antibiotics, it is necessary to
stratify patients based on evidence that supports the presence of an etiologic
agent.
Association of Crohn’s Disease with Mycobacterium avium ss. Paratuberculosis
MAP is the etiologic agent that causes Johne’s disease, a chronic inflammatory
bowel condition in animals, such as ruminants and primates.
There are a number of histological similarities between CD and Johne’s
disease.2
MAP has been suspected as a possible etiological agent of CD. The association
of CD and MAP has been strengthened by cumulative studies.
Studies have isolated MAP from CD tissue3,4,5 and lymph nodes6. A recent
study has isolated and cultured MAP from CD breast milk and CD resected
tissue.7,8
Stratification of CD patients with p35 and p36 recombinant clones
MAP recombinant antigens (p35 and p36) individually and combined have
been shown to have a statistically significant difference in reactivity
between Crohn’s disease-positive serum and serum samples from controls
(Ulcerative colitis and healthy controls).9
The recombinant clones p35 and p36 express 35- and 36 kDa proteins,
respectively, and were identified from a previously constructed expression
genomic library of MAP.10
p35 encoding gene expresses a 35K protein that reacts well with sera
from Johne’s animals11 while the p36 encoding gene has been sequenced (AF048899)
and expresses a protein that is considered a Mycobacterium-genus specific
antigen.12
Treatment Strategies for Mycobacterium avium ss. Paratuberculosis
Once there is evidence to support a possible MAP infection, combination
antibiotic therapy can be tailored to eradicate mycobcateria both intracellularly
and extracellularly.
The combination of clarithromycin and rifabutin have been shown to produce
additive effect against both intra-cellular and extra-cellular replication
of Mycobacterium avium.13
Two-year outcome study using rifabutin and macrolide antibiotic therapy
(RMAT) demonstrated that 93.5% of CD patients treated went into clinical
remission.14
Next >>>